Visit us at: 30 Good Minutes.org
 
         

Paul Cohen
"You Are Never Alone"
Program #5109
First broadcast December 2, 2007

Biography
Rabbi Paul Cohen is Senior Rabbi of Temple Jeremiah in Northfield, Illinois. Originally from Chicago, he has served synagogues in Arkansas, Ohio, Virginia and Maine. He’s had a long interest in interfaith relations and received a Doctor of Ministry degree from the Bangor Theological Seminary, which is associated with the United Church of Christ. [Biographical information is correct as of the broadcast date noted above.]

Watch the video 
Watch the video interview 
Download Audio.mp3
  Please right-click the link to display your browser's "save as" options.
View the entire transcript of this program (.PDF format)

 

_________________
 

"You Are Never Alone"
How is it that we find the strength to endure times of deep darkness? How is it that we are able to move forward with our lives when we feel completely lost and alone, when we are devoid of courage, when we feel all hope is lost? Judaism doesn't necessarily provide us with answers to these questions, but more appropriately responses to these questions. For each of us, the response may be different. And so I'd like to begin first with a story that may be familiar. I think it's told in many different religious contexts and also in secular contexts.

The story is of a man. Let's call him Jacob. Jacob is living in a town where there has been a very heavy rainfall and the rain is continuing to come down at a very rapid rate. The creek that flows through the center of the town has begun to fill and it is threatening to flood the entire town. People are calling to one another to evacuate their homes, to leave their residences, to flee to safety. Jacob has always prided himself on being a very pious individual, one with a complete and perfect faith in God. And so as his friends are gathering around and trying to convince him to leave his home, he says to them, “No, no, no. I'm going to stay right where I am. I am secure in my faith. I know that God will protect me.” Well, his friends continue to argue with him and they try to get him to change his mind but he remains unmoved, relying on God and his faith in God to protect him from any danger that might come through these floodwaters.

The waters continue to rise as the rain continues to fall. Soon the water has covered the street and is coming up the steps to his porch. People continue to evacuate the town, although this time they're not walking on foot, they are in boats. Again, a friend comes by in a boat—in a rowboat—and says to Jacob, “Jacob, come! Flee with me to safety. This is becoming much too dangerous. You have to come with us. You must protect yourself.” Again, Jacob says, “I have perfect faith in God. I know that God is with me, that God will protect me from these floodwaters. I don't need the help of the rowboat. Thank you very much, but I don't need your help either. God is enough for me. I will rely and place my trust and my faith in God.” Well, the friend in the rowboat continues on and helps other people in need and more accepting of his help.

The floodwaters by now are continuing to rise into the first floor. The first floor of Jacob's house is now filled with water. He has to flee up the steps to the second floor of his house. The water continues to rise. This time the police come by in a motorboat and they plead with Jacob to leave his home. Jacob says, “My faith is in God. Thank you very much for your offer, but God will protect me. I feel safe in the knowledge that God is always a presence in my life. God would not let any harm come to me. I'm a man of complete faith.” The police continue on their way rescuing others who are accepting of their help.

Finally, the water has completely covered the second floor. Jacob is now on the rooftop of his house. A helicopter comes by and calls out to Jacob, “Jacob, the waters are completely covering your house. You're on the roof. Come to safety. Flee with us to safety. Accept our help and come into the helicopter.” They lower a rope ladder to him and Jacob, at this point, still refuses. He says, “I am a man of complete faith. I trust in God. God will help me through this time of danger, through this time of trial. God is with me as a presence in my life. I know that God will not let any harm come to me.”

Well, the waters completely cover Jacob's house and Jacob is swept away by the waters. Jacob winds up in heaven. He is a little bit upset and confused, and even a little bit angry that his faith in God has not served him, that he did not survive the flood, that his life is now over. He demands to speak with God. God accepts this request, accepts this demand. Jacob is standing before the throne of glory demanding to know what happened. Why had God abandoned Jacob in his time of need? After all, Jacob had been a very pious, pious person and had lived a life of complete and perfect faith and lived a good life. Why was it that he was abandoned by God? God said to Jacob, “I was present with you at every step along the way. First, I sent your friends. Then I sent the rowboat. Then I sent the motorboat. And finally I sent the helicopter. Jacob, you refused to accept any of this help that was offered to you.” The message of this story is that sometimes in our time of crisis, when we are looking to God for our faith, that we must instead look to other people. It's very clear to Jacob in the end that having faith in God is so important but having faith in human beings and your community and your friends is also very, very important.

This is the lesson that another Jacob learned, this time in chapter 28 of the book of Genesis. Read the story of Jacob and his brother, Esau. Jacob's life is a struggle from its very inception. He and his brother Esau are engaged in combat. So much so that it caused Rebecca, their mother, tremendous pain and she seeks to understand what is happening to her. God tells her that there are two nations within her womb and that they will be in struggle with one another. Jacob is born and the family situation does not improve. His mother loves him more than Esau. His father loves Esau more than him, setting up an intense conflict from which he will struggle to recover. He steals his brother's birthright and then later steals the blessing of the firstborn. By the stealing of the firstborn blessing, he is counseled by his mother to flee his home because surely Esau will kill him. So he must abandon his home, abandon his family, abandon all that is familiar and continue to cope with the guilt that he must feel at having caused so much devastation within his home, within his own life. He comes to a place that is so completely desolate, so completely devoid of life, that he has to use a rock as a pillow.

It is there that he has a dream, a dream in which he sees a ladder going up to heaven and the angels are going up and down the ladder. At the top of the ladder he sees the very face of God. He wakes up from this dream and he understands that God remains present with him, even in such a desolate place. He utters a sentence of complete surprise, “How awesome is this place. Surely God is here and I did not know it.” It's a transforming experience in a time of a feeling of complete abandonment, of feeling loss and no hope, completely cut off from his family of origin. It is there when he opens himself up in that desert, in that place of desolation that he able to not only feel the presence of God in his life but also to have this dream that tells him that the angels which are coming from the Earth and going up to heaven, are sages of blessed memory to council us, not divine beings but are human beings. They are the people that he will encounter in the coming days and weeks that will help him to not only survive and to come through this crisis, but to thrive and to continue to grow. So Jacob, in recognition of what has happened to him, says that he will dedicate one tenth of everything that he acquires and he will dedicate that to God. This is really the first mention in the Bible of giving back, of sharing, what in Hebrew is called tzedakah , an act of not only charity but an act of righteousness. And so that it's not just through other people that Jacob will be able to overcome this time of deep darkness, but it is through serving other people, through providing of his own wealth, of his own material goods that he will be able to grow and to return to a sense of wholeness and to return to his home, as well.

Just a few weeks ago, I had the opportunity to talk with a family in preparation for a funeral. One of the things they shared with me about this gentleman who has just passed was that he had lived more than fifty years with intense chronic pain. They couldn't understand how he was able to endure this pain, how he was able to get up in the morning to go through the day and continue to live his life with a pain that was so great at times it brought tears to his eyes. As I listened to them talk about this man and what he meant to them, it became very clear to me how it was that he was able to survive, how he was able to endure. It was through the love of his family. The recognizing that those relationships were so important and that caring for his family—not only just receiving their care but being able to provide for them through his work and being able to love them and be present for them—was the best relief for the pain that he continued to endure through his life. At one point, one of his sons asked him how he was able to bear the pain, how it was he was able to keep on with each day. He said to his son—referring to the son's mother, his wife—“I'm hanging in because of her.” He was able to endure this tremendous pain in his life because of the love that he felt, for not only his wife, not only for his children, but for his grandchildren as well. This was the secret to how he was able to endure.

These are just a few of the responses that come to us through Jewish tradition. We are able to endure times of crisis when we are able to not only look towards God but to look towards God's creation, to look to our fellow human beings. Sometimes the endurance, the strength that we need to survive a time of deep darkness, comes when we are able to look outside of ourselves and to turn to the needs of others. And sometimes it is the love of our family that helps us to endure the chronic pain that is a part of life.

I would like to share with you words that were written by Naomi Levy, words of a prayer that I find to be of tremendous comfort in times of personal crisis. She writes:

Teach me always to believe in my power to return to life, to hope, and to you, my God. No matter what pains I have endured, no matter how far I have strayed from you, give me the strength to resurrect my weary spirit. Revive me, God, and I will embrace life once more in joy, in passion, and in peace. Amen.

Conversation with Paul Cohen

Lydia Talbot: What an inspiring message on endurance, Paul! Thank you for that. You are a marathon runner. I know you've done the Chicago Marathon in the past so you know, in terms of athletics and sports, what endurance is as a test of strength. But I've got to ask you personally as you think back over your life, what's the most dramatic personal experience that you've had with endurance as a test of your own faith?

Paul Cohen: I think the time I would like to share is the time when my third child was born, my daughter, Anna. It was a very difficult delivery and it was a time of incredible darkness. I thought that I was going to lose Cathy. I spent hours and hours in the hospital wondering what was going to happen next and whether I would lose my life partner, whether she would be able to recover or not. I already had tried to play out how I would be able to move on, assuming the worst, and what would I be able to. In those moments I felt that God was sending me—just like for Jacob—little angels and messengers: doctors, nurses, members of my congregation, friends who would come by. Not that they gave magic words that helped me to feel better, but it was through their presence, through a simple touch on the arm, an embrace, simply sitting with me, that gave me the strength to endure that time which was for me a tremendous darkness.

Daniel Pawlus: Paul, you've touched on this idea of endurance through community which I think is a wonderful thing.

Cohen: Yes.

Pawlus: Often times we think we have to grin and bear it ourselves as individuals. The Jewish people and the Jewish faith are certainly full of endurance. How do you address that on a regular basis with the temple and your faith community?

Cohen: Well, I think that a part of the answer is in the question itself. That is when the Jewish community, when a particular community is feeling threatened or in crisis, being able to turn to one another is the way that we are able to derive strength. Knowing that we're not in this alone, that we can turn to one another even as we turn to God. There is a story that I share that is actually at the end, oddly enough, of the wedding ceremony. It's when we break the glass at the end of the ceremony and we're able to talk about the significance of this event. I always connect it back to the breaking of the first set of tablets at Mount Sinai when Moses has been away for forty days and forty nights and the people felt completely abandoned and alone. They don't feel that Moses is ever going to return. They feel completely abandoned by God. And instead of turning to one another, they turn to the calf of gold. Moses comes down the mountain, sees them dancing and singing around this calf of gold and out of frustration and anger, takes the tablets and throws them to the ground. They shatter into thousands of pieces. And the way I relate this to the wedding is to talk about how the breaking of the glass is an echo of that moment because the Israelites from that moment forward understood that they had to dedicate their lives to strengthening the bonds of friendship and love between themselves in order to not only survive crisis but also to enhance moments of joy. I think that's been the message that we have carried forward through the generations, that when we are together, when are united, we can survive most anything. We turn to each other and together we turn to God.

Talbot: I love your emphasis—the reoccurring emphasis through your message and what you've shared now—about the presence of God in the midst of our pain and suffering. Your stories about the two Jacobs remind us that God is not a magician. God cannot prevent disasters or tragedies or death or loss, but God is not absent from them. So when you're talking about illness—in the earlier video that we saw of Martha Foster struggling with breast cancer and brain cancer—what are the words that you tell your flock at Temple Jeremiah when they are facing serious illness?

Cohen: The responses are different based on how people are coming to me. What are the questions that are being asked. Sometimes people ask: “Why is God doing this to me? Why am I suffering? I've been a good person, why do I have cancer now? Why can't I have a child now? Why is God doing this to me?” I try to help them reframe the question. I don't think that's a helpful question to ask because it pushes God away or it puts blame where blame shouldn't be placed. It blocks the movement forward. So what I gently try and guide them towards is, it's not why is God doing this to you, it's what meaning can I find in what's happening to me. Not “Why is this happening?” but “What am I able to learn? How can I move forward with this?” Sometimes people dedicate their lives after they've survived an illness to helping others. Sometimes it gives them a new strength to face other challenges in their lives. But what I try to do is help them find the right question and also to pair them up with people who have had a similar experience. Again it's that sense of community. You're not the only person who has struggled in this way or asked these questions. Let me connect you with somebody else and they can help.

Talbot: So life is gift in every breath we take.

Cohen: Yes.

Pawlus: We've enjoyed so much spending time with you, Paul. Thank you for being here today.

Cohen: Thank you for having me.     
 
 
_____________________________________________________________________